Apple, Lenovo lead pack of high-powered laptops
Government Computer News reviews devices that can tackle nearly any PC job
- By Nick Wakeman
- Aug 05, 2010
Apple’s 15-inch MacBook Pro and Lenovo’s ThinkPad W510 both received reviewer’s choice recognition in a review of high-powered laptops by Government Computer News’ testing lab.
The GCN Lab tested devices from Apple, Lenovo, Fujitsu, Hewlett-Packard, Samsung and Sony Vaio.
The Lab used PassMark’s Performance Test 7 software, which has 28 benchmark tests covering areas such as CPUs, graphics, disks and memory. The Lab also put the laptop’s batteries through their paces.
Read the entire laptop review
Can the Apple iPad get any workplace respect?
None of the laptops was found to be a poor performer according to the PassMark tests. The reviewers found the group of devices all to be powerful computers, calling them a “bevy of true powerhouse laptops ready for any task a busy government employee can throw at them.”
Apple had the highest battery life and good performance but was knocked for the limited number of ports. It received a value score of B-plus. It received praise for its touchpad, which is large and has many of the touch-screen features popular on the Apple iPhone and iPad.
The Lenovo had the best overall performance with an A-minus value score. Its lowest score was a B-plus for ergonomics. The reviewers praised the Lenovo for its built-in fingerprint scanner and its plethora of ports.
Among the other laptops reviewed:
- Fujitsu America: Value score B-plus, but was knocked for it low battery life and low performance. It scored well with its large variety of ports and slots.
- HP EliteBook: Value score: B, but it had a short battery life and heavy weight (6-pounds, 7 ounces). Its performance score was an A.
- Samsung P580: Value score: A, but was found to have a short battery life. The price ($999) was praised, but the reviewers found that it is probably best for short work trips.
- Sony Vaio EB: Value score: A, but was knocked for its low performance. Its low price of $850 and roomy interface were big pluses for the reviewers.
Nick Wakeman is the editor-in-chief of Washington Technology. Follow him on Twitter: @nick_wakeman.