By Steve Kelman

Blog archive

Final impressions of China: Land of contradictions

China is an amazing, fascinating country, but as I leave from my most recent trip, I am again impressed by contradictory images one gets of the country.

My final reminder came on my flight out of China, on Air China. The movie selection consisted of everything from Disney movies to “The East is Red,” the Mao Zedong era “opera.” I tried to watch “The Birth of the Republic,” a big-budget extravaganza about the final years of the Chinese civil war and the proclamation of Communist rule in 1949, made on the sixtieth anniversary of the event in 2009. But before the movie, a paean to Chairman Mao, began, there was an ad for…Mercedes Benz cars. (Incidentally, I say I “tried” to watch the movie because, although the airline magazine said the flick had English subtitles, in fact it didn’t. So I ended up watching a fun, mindless Chinese entertainment movie, called “Sophie’s Revenge,” about a girl’s effort to take revenge on the boyfriend who dumped her –with the characters all clearly inhabitants of a young, hip, wealthy Chinese world. I would be curious to hear from Chinese readers about the Chinese-language name of the sixtieth-anniversary movie, rendered into harmless English as birth of “the republic”; I am guessing the Chinese version refers to birth of the “People’s Republic.”)

The materialism of Chinese society in general and the wealthy in particular is a big theme in China. China Daily featured an op-ed while I was there, “The Gold-Digging Game,” which attacked TV shows in which bachelors are paraded to talk about themselves in front of 24 female contestants (the contestants turn off a light if they decide they aren’t interested in the guy; the guy then gets to choose one of the girls who leave the lights on). What the article found deplorable was the crass materialism of these shows. On one show, a guy showed his apartment ownership certificate, keys to a Lamborghini, and a diamond ring; on another show, a woman said, “I’d rather be miserable sitting in a BMW than be happy riding a bicycle.” The article wistfully noted that in U.S. dating shows – in our land of materialism and capitalism -- contestants are forbidden from mentioning salary or profession.

This raises the issue of the other big contradictory image one receives of China: Is it a powerful country about to take over the world, or a poor, developing country rife with social problems? It is difficult to know whether the humbler image is one designed more for western consumption (and that Chinese actually believe that their ancient civilization, after a bad patch that lasted several centuries, is going back to its traditional position of being the most important country in the world). But the impression I get from talking with academics and some officials, and from reading the English-language media, is closer to the second image than the first.

China’s economic boom – led by factory and infrastructure investment – has left lots of people, even in the big cities, with stagnant incomes and facing skyrocketing housing prices, as the share of national income going to wages and salaries has plummeted to a rate well below that of any other major country in the world. Chinese now talk about an “ant tribe” of young white-collar workers in the big cities, living in tiny apartments and hardly able to make ends meet. And of course the situation of people in the rural villages, and in the factories recently rocked by strikes over low wages, is far worse. The pollution remains terrible – during my week in China, a disgusting, and cough-inducing, pea soup enveloped the three cities I saw, and I didn’t see the sun once. So there seems to be an emerging consensus that China needs to pay people better, and move to higher-value added (and less-polluting) service industries. Both of these changes will involve major stresses for the Chinese economy and society (for a good article on Chinese economic issues, read “Economic Weather Getting Stormy” by Pang Zhongying).

P.S. Some blog readers may remember that I am studying the Chinese language. I am a firm believer in the linguistic equivalent to “no pain, no gain” – just try to speak and say things in the foreign language, even at the risk of making mistakes. The possible consequences of this were revealed at a going-away dinner with faculty and students at Xi’an’s Jiaotong University, when I was trying to discuss (in Chinese) how Americans don’t have the same aversion to eating alone as Chinese do. I wanted to say, “When I am in China and eat alone…” However, by putting the phrase “alone” (yi ge ren) after the verb instead of before, what I said became, “When I am in China and eat a person…” Oh, well.

Posted by Steve Kelman on Jun 29, 2010 at 7:26 PM

Reader Comments

Fri, Jul 9, 2010 Gang of three BJ

Hey, person eater! An interesting blog. Referring to the contradiction, I don't think it's a black-or-white question, but corelated questions. As I watch and experience more and more in this country, I find that the image of a boosting powerful country is what the government wants to build in front of western countries. However, many ordinary ppl in China are extremly humble and poor and lving their traditions (I'm not talking about those who are on the Blind Date TV shows). Thus, when the government strives to look good and to take over the world, they would firstly sacrifice the humble ppl's interests,which leads to many social problems. The more the country wants to look good, the poorer ppl get, and the more the humble ppl suffer.

Fri, Jul 2, 2010 Di Gua

Steve, your final impressions are very interesting!! It's even hard to Chinese to understand ourselves. I think China is a powerful country with severe social problems.And one of the biggest problems is polarization.

Fri, Jul 2, 2010 Adrian Fisk

Steve - I was directed to your blog by a Chinese journalist friend of mine. I find your writing relevant, interesting and it reflected some of my own takes on the country. I worked on an extensive photo series in China recently with the aim to look at and try and understand some of the Chinese youth and what they think about life. The project is titled 'iSpeak China', I think you and others would find the results interesting. It can be found here on my newly launched site - www.adrianfisk.com

Tue, Jun 29, 2010 jie md

Steve ,it is so interesting ,you grasp the most popular events that happened in China,the movie name in Chinese is "Jian Guo Da Ye",it if is a movie,but there is a Tv series in similar content named"zou xiang gong he"., Actually when china learn from western country,she also lost its cultural elite.

Please post your comments here. Comments are moderated, so they may not appear immediately after submitting. We will not post comments that we consider abusive or off-topic.

Please type the letters/numbers you see above

What is your e-mail address?

My e-mail address is:

Do you have a password?

Forgot your password? Click here


  • Dive into our Contract Award database

    In an exclusive for WT Insider members, we are collecting all of the contract awards we cover into a database that you can sort by contractor, agency, value and other parameters. You can also download it into a spreadsheet. Our databases track awards back to 2013. Read More

  • Navigating the trends and issues of 2016 Nick Wakeman

    In our latest WT Insider Report, we pull together our best advice, insights and reporting on the trends and issues that will shape the market in 2016 and beyond. Read More

contracts DB

Washington Technology Daily

Sign up for our newsletter.

Terms and Privacy Policy consent

I agree to this site's Privacy Policy.