Coalition attacks Real ID Act regulations
- By Alice Lipowicz
- May 02, 2007
Forty-three civil liberties and consumer organizations have started a national campaign
against the Real ID Act regulations issued by the Homeland Security Department because they believe the new identification system will have serious negative impacts on privacy and civil rights.
The campaign was announced Tuesday and seven additional groups joined today, bringing the total involved to 50. The purpose of the effort is "to stop the nation's first national ID system," the coalition said.
The groups say they are worried about increased threat of counterfeiting and identity theft due to lack of security to protect against unauthorized access to the information on the ID cards.
Furthermore, they object to the expense of the cards and to individuals' loss of privacy and loss of control of their personal information if the cards are breached or misused. Some civil libertarians suggest the negative consequences of a national ID card system could be extreme ? such as permitting unprecedented government tracking of individuals and possibly hindering authorizations for jobs, medical care or housing ? if the information is stolen or abused.
"Under the act, states and federal government would share access to a vast national database that could include images of birth certificates, marriage licenses, divorce papers, court ordered separations, medical records and detailed information on the name, date of birth, race, religion, ethnicity, gender, address, telephone, e-mail address and Social Security number for more than 240 million (people), with no requirements or controls on how this database might be used," the coalition said.
The Real ID Act of 2005 was passed by Congress on the recommendation of the 9/11 Commission to standardize state-issued drivers' licenses nationwide to curb abuses and prevent illegal aliens from obtaining ID cards through use of false information. Several of the 9/11 terrorists were in possession of valid U.S. driver's licenses.
However, several state legislatures have rejected the Real ID Act requirements. To date, Arkansas, Idaho, Maine, Montana and Washington have voted not to participate in implementing the Real ID Act due to its high costs and to privacy concerns. State governments will have to spend about $11 billion on Real ID over five years, according to a September 2006 study by the National Conference on State Legislatures, National Governors Association and the American Association of Motor Vehicle Administrators.
The civil liberties groups also are concerned about increased costs for obtaining a license or state issued ID card, and possibly "arbitrary and capricious" decisions at state agencies that may hinder them from obtaining the ID card.
Public comments are due on the Real ID Act regulations by May 8.
Alice Lipowicz is a staff writer covering government 2.0, homeland security and other IT policies for Federal Computer Week.